Learning Humility Through La Rochefoucauld's Insights
Written on
Chapter 1: Understanding La Rochefoucauld's Life and Work
François de La Rochefoucauld, born in Paris in 1613, is not the first person you might consider a role model. His life was fraught with challenges and hardships. The Maxims he published in 1665 consist of brief aphorisms, typically one or two sentences in length, that reflect a certain cynicism, often exposing the less admirable aspects of human nature. Some notable examples include:
- "We all possess enough strength to bear the troubles of others."
- "We lack the strength to follow our reason fully."
- "To achieve success in society, individuals strive to appear successful."
But can we derive meaningful lessons from someone who appears to revel in highlighting our shortcomings? The answer may be yes.
Think about the qualities of a genuine friend. Such a friend will point out your faults, not to belittle you, but to aid your personal growth. If we approach La Rochefoucauld’s Maxims with this mindset, we can uncover valuable lessons, particularly about humility.
La Rochefoucauld addresses humility directly in a limited number of maxims, describing it as "merely feigned submissiveness" in one instance. Nevertheless, we can glean insights about humility from his reflections on pride, luck, and chance.
Section 1.1: The Nature of Pride
To understand humility, we must first examine pride. La Rochefoucauld asserts, "All men share an equal amount of pride; the only distinction lies in how it is displayed." This observation serves as a reminder that pride is a common human trait. But is pride inherently negative? Not necessarily. He argues, "Pride, which incites our envy, also helps to keep it in check."
Interestingly, one flaw can often counterbalance another. While pride may help regulate envy, what occurs when we seek to minimize other faults? We tend to take pride in our achievements! "Our pride often flourishes on what we eliminate from our other flaws."
This brings to mind Aristotle's concept of the golden mean, which he employs to discuss virtues. Balance is crucial. Courage is a virtue, yet excessive courage can lead to recklessness, while insufficient courage results in cowardice. La Rochefoucauld suggests that a similar balance applies to our faults. We cannot completely eradicate them; they serve to balance one another.
However, we must remember that our faults are double-edged swords. While they can serve as counterweights, they may also conflict with our virtues. "The very pride that leads us to condemn flaws we believe we don't possess causes us to undervalue the good qualities we lack."
None of us is without flaws, and the traits we criticize in others may be ones we need to cultivate within ourselves. Once we nurture these qualities and address our faults, we may take pride in our achievements. However, this isn't always straightforward.
Section 1.2: The Role of Luck and Chance
We often take pride in our successes, believing they stem from our efforts. Yet, "although individuals take pride in their noble deeds, these are rarely the result of a grand design but rather mere chance." We frequently overlook the significant role luck and chance play in our lives, both positively and negatively.
When people recount their success stories, they tend to emphasize their actions as the main contributors. Nevertheless, "while nature grants advantages, it is not solely nature but luck that creates heroes."
We also misjudge the effects of fortune. Many believe that good fortune will yield more happiness than it does, and that bad fortune will cause greater misery. For instance, lottery winners often experience a temporary surge in happiness before returning to their baseline level of contentment. Similarly, those who face adversity typically see a decline in happiness, but it too eventually returns to normal. As La Rochefoucauld puts it, "We are never as fortunate or as unfortunate as we believe."
Luck and chance are indifferent to their consequences; however, we often presume otherwise. Those who enjoy good fortune may mistakenly view it as a reward for merit. Consequently, "Fortunate individuals seldom change their ways, for when luck rewards their misdeeds with success, they assume it is because they are right."
While luck and chance are not bound by moral considerations, they can reveal a person's true character. "Chance exposes virtues and vices as light reveals objects." One can learn much about a person by observing their reactions to both good and bad fortune.
Some individuals excel at converting misfortune into opportunity, while others can squander success. As La Rochefoucauld notes, "No misfortune is so severe that the astute cannot turn it to their advantage, nor is any fortune so favorable that the reckless cannot turn it to their detriment."
This Stoic perspective echoes Seneca's assertion that "No man finds poverty troublesome except for the one who perceives it as such." It is not the situation that causes distress, but our mindset. Luck and chance will occur; what matters is how we interpret these experiences.
Chapter 2: Lessons from La Rochefoucauld
In the video "François de la Rochefoucauld's 'Moral Maxims' and Influence on Friedrich Nietzsche," we explore how La Rochefoucauld's thoughts influenced later philosophers, particularly Nietzsche, and how his insights remain relevant today.
The second video, "Reflections; or Sentences and Moral Maxims. By La Rochefoucauld. Full Length Audiobook," offers a complete auditory experience of his maxims, allowing deeper engagement with his reflections.
In conclusion, can we learn valuable lessons from La Rochefoucauld despite his apparent intentions? Perhaps. He observes that "We give nothing so freely as our advice," suggesting he includes himself in this observation. He also notes, "We provide advice, yet we do not influence people's behavior."
Ultimately, we must interpret and apply his insights as we see fit. Indeed, "Sometimes, it requires just as much cleverness to benefit from wise counsel as it does to conceive the advice oneself." Perhaps my interpretations are overly clever.
I began by suggesting that La Rochefoucauld could serve as that critical friend aimed at fostering growth. He asserts as much in the Maxims, highlighting that "The most challenging aspect of friendship is not revealing our faults to a friend but enabling them to recognize their own." If La Rochefoucauld achieves anything in his Maxims, it is making us aware of our shortcomings. By reading his aphorisms in this spirit, we can extract wisdom from his incisive observations.
And perhaps we can appreciate La Rochefoucauld's assertion that "While true love may be rare, true friendship is even rarer."