Chapter 1: The Misinterpretation of Irony

Irony is often misunderstood, leading to widespread misuse of the term. A personal experience illustrates this common mistake.

I went to the beach with a close friend in Florida. He’s naturally muscular, almost like a bodybuilder after just a few pushups, but his pale skin burns easily, much like an Irish albino. Despite applying a strong 80-proof sunscreen multiple times, he ended up looking like he was covered in a layer of white clay, attracting curious glances from passersby. In the end, even with all that effort, he still got sunburned. He remarked, “Wow. After all that, I’m still burned. That’s ironic.” While I appreciate him, I must clarify: that wasn’t irony; it was unfortunate.

Many people frequently label situations as ironic. In fact, in 2010, Dictionary.com declared “irony” to be the most misused term in English. I can’t quite pinpoint why this misuse irritates me so much, but perhaps it’s because, as a writer, I become increasingly particular about language. This meticulousness is often seen in English teachers, who are known for their detail-oriented and sometimes pedantic nature. Unlike math, which is straightforward and concrete, English often involves subjective interpretations and artistic expression. Yet, despite its fluidity, language still adheres to certain rules.

People frequently engage in heated online debates regarding the definition of irony. I’ve encountered this discussion on various platforms, where individuals become entangled in arguments over what does and does not qualify as ironic. They often seize upon a minute detail of my examples to make their point.

To clarify, there are different kinds of irony, but my focus is on the most prevalent type: situational irony.

Section 1.1: A Common Misunderstanding: Literally vs. Ironically

Another term that suffers similar misuse is “literally.” For example, someone might say, “I was literally about to go insane at this concert.”

A useful trick to determine if something is genuinely ironic involves inserting the phrase “the very thing.” For instance, if someone were to die from a sunburn after applying maximum-proof sunscreen, that wouldn’t be ironic; it would simply be unfortunate. However, if the Egyptian Sun God, Ra, were to succumb to sunburn, that would indeed be ironic. Why? Because he was the very deity associated with the sun, and the very thing he ruled over became his downfall.

In the sunscreen case, we can’t apply the “the very thing” test, as sunscreen doesn’t guarantee protection from sunburn. Also, the situation lacks a surprising twist, which is essential for situational irony.

Subsection 1.1.1: Examples to Illuminate Irony

Consider the anecdote about Charlie Chaplin, who allegedly entered a lookalike contest of himself and placed 20th. Regardless of its truth, this story serves as a classic example of irony.

Another true instance involves William Phelps Eno, often referred to as the “Father of Road Safety,” who invented the stop sign but never learned to drive. Ironically, he was still awarded an honorary driver’s license:

Chapter 2: The Pinnacle of Irony Misuse

The ultimate example of irony misuse can be found in Alanis Morissette's song “Ironic,” where none of the situations described actually qualify as ironic.

The lyrics depict unfortunate coincidences rather than true irony, such as the line “It’s like rain on your wedding day,” which is simply an unfortunate occurrence.

Some argue that the second verse contains actual irony, where a man afraid of flying dies on his first flight. For it to be truly ironic, his fear would need to cause him to go mad and inadvertently crash the plane.

Ironically, the song itself serves as a meta commentary on misunderstanding irony, illustrating that perhaps Morissette didn’t fully grasp the concept—or maybe she did, and it was all intentional.

I’m not trying to belittle anyone; I genuinely appreciate Alanis Morissette and her album, Jagged Little Pill. Like any writer, I too make mistakes. My exploration of irony is part of my journey to better understand it.

A Final Trick for Understanding Situational Irony

Perhaps it’s most useful to view irony as a spectrum ranging from zero to 100. Ideally, you want your situation to score close to 100. For an event to exemplify full-blown situational irony, it should fulfill three criteria:

1. The outcome should be the opposite of what was expected.
2. It should present a surprising result.
3. It should evoke amusement, often in a darkly humorous way.

In essence, it’s a plot twist that elicits a smile, albeit sometimes morbidly.

Subscribe to Relax and Read for more enlightening content.