The Role of Right Desire in Reincarnation and Dhamma
Written on
Chapter 1: Understanding Right Desire
To initiate change, one must cultivate the right desires.
One's motivation should stem from the aspiration to prevent negative mental states. This involves making an effort, energizing oneself, focusing the mind, and striving towards improvement.
Similarly, one should seek to abandon negative mental states through concerted effort and determination. The aim is to encourage the emergence of positive mental states, ensuring their persistence, enhancement, and complete development through dedicated effort.
— The Buddha
These teachings underscore the vital role of desire in the process of effort. Without a genuine desire to change, efforts become futile. For example, recognizing an addiction is the first step, but the real transformation occurs when there is a desire to overcome it. Without this wish, no real effort will follow.
This illustrates the principle of right desire. In Buddhism, not all desires are deemed negative; some can be constructive.
Contrary to Christianity, Buddhism does not categorize desires as sinful. The negative mental states mentioned earlier refer to those that lead to suffering, whereas positive states are those that alleviate suffering. Gaining this understanding can spark the desire to engage in meaningful effort. The ultimate aim of Buddhism is to realize the cessation of suffering — a goal that resonates with everyone.
Everything in Buddhism is transient, except for one state: Nibbana. Upon achieving Nibbana and becoming an arahant (a fully awakened being), this state is permanent and irrevocable. Such individuals are liberated from the cycle of rebirth and do not return to any realm after their current life concludes.
This liberation is significant because even celestial realms are not free from suffering. Devas (heavenly beings) experience loss and grief, and their long, comfortable lives can lead to complacency, causing them to neglect the virtues that allowed their rebirth in those realms. Once the karmic energy that sustains their existence is depleted, they face death, and depending on their karmic history, they may be reborn as humans, often experiencing profound shock and distress.
The human experience can feel excruciatingly tough in comparison to a deva's life. Although a being may not consciously recall their previous existence as a deva, there remains an innate yearning for that lost state, manifesting as a persistent dissatisfaction with the human experience. This can lead to struggles with employment and a sense of unfulfillment, potentially resulting in depression and a desire to escape existence altogether.
While rebirth as a deva may seem preferable to returning to the human realm, it does not resolve suffering permanently. For many, it merely postpones the inevitable return to this world. This cyclical nature of existence, known as Samsara, can be harsh, underscoring the importance of breaking free from this cycle. However, most beings remain unaware of how karma operates.
Birth invariably leads to suffering. Regardless of where one is born, it culminates in death, separation from loved ones, grief, and lamentation. For those ignorant of karma, the uncertainty of their next existence adds to their plight.
Some celestial beings, however, remain aware and continue to cultivate positive karma in their realms, ensuring their reincarnation as devas. A select few attain complete liberation within the heavenly realms, having eradicated greed and hatred, thus preventing their return to the human world. Yet, they still harbor a subtle attachment to existence, which is why they are reborn as devas.
In contemporary society, particularly in the West, it can be challenging to accept these concepts. Many individuals operate from a scientific and skeptical standpoint, often believing in the finality of death. While it is reasonable to adopt this perspective, I find it difficult to reconcile with my intuition and encounters with spiritual phenomena, which suggest a continuation of existence beyond this life.
The Buddha presented reincarnation as a fundamental reality, outlining a complex cosmology where beings are born and die in accordance with their actions (kamma).
In the Buddha's era, as today, some philosophers contended that this life is singular and final. The Buddha, however, opposed such views, and I find myself aligned with his teachings on reincarnation and karma. This perspective resonates deeply with me, embodying a truth that, while subjective and unprovable, feels profoundly real.
Section 1.1: The Impermanence of Existence
Section 1.2: The Nature of Suffering
Chapter 2: Reincarnation and Its Implications
This video addresses questions surrounding reincarnation, exploring concepts from Kabbalah and their connections to the teachings of the Buddha.
This video examines the reasons behind belief in reincarnation, delving into various perspectives and cultural contexts.