Human Nature

First and foremost, recognize this fundamental truth: everyone makes mistakes. It's a part of the job. Most individuals learn from their errors and rarely repeat them.

Remember that you are dealing with intelligent and capable professionals. Therefore, your approach shouldn't be to reprimand or bulldoze them at the first hint of a mistake.

Another crucial point is that people can evolve. Don’t cling to past errors as if they define a person's capabilities. Real leaders are inherently optimistic, believing in their team's potential for growth. Just because someone struggled in the past doesn’t mean they can’t excel now.

Many managers hold on to outdated narratives about their employees. Avoid being that kind of leader. Offer your team a clean slate.

Pre-conversation Considerations

What happens when you inform someone that their performance is lacking? They are likely to become defensive or withdrawn—an entirely natural response.

Thus, it's vital to approach these discussions as a dialogue rather than a monologue. Always start with curiosity and ask open-ended questions to promote self-awareness.

Try utilizing powerful questions such as: "What happened with X?" or "What could you have done differently?" Your objective should be to understand them first and then guide them toward solutions.

Navigating the Conversation

Let’s state the obvious—keep these discussions private. Public criticisms are rarely justified and should be avoided at all costs.

Address issues promptly; don’t let them simmer. Aim to collect your thoughts within a few days at most.

Start the conversation with something like, "I have something important to discuss, and I realize it might be tough to hear," or "I dislike this aspect of my job, but we need to have a conversation."

Stick to the facts and avoid unnecessary embellishments. For instance, rather than saying, "Yesterday, John mentioned you might miss your milestone for the seventh time during Tuesday’s project meeting," simply state, "I’m concerned about these missed deadlines. Can we talk about it?"

Then listen actively. They may need support or resources, or they might just want an empathetic ear. Follow up with, "How can I assist you?" This demonstrates that you’re on their side.

Finally, wrap up the conversation with, "What are our agreed-upon steps?" or "What’s our plan moving forward?"

Closing Thoughts

See? It’s not so daunting after all. Providing constructive feedback is about uplifting your team rather than tearing them down. You can convey your message without undermining their confidence.

It’s not merely what you communicate but how you communicate it that matters.

Thank you for engaging with this content! If you found it valuable, consider following me and showing some support so that others can benefit as well!

P.S. I offer more than just insights through The Saturday Power Move.

1. ☕ Free Coffee Chat: Ready to transform your leadership approach? Let’s discuss how I can help you evolve your style over a virtual coffee.
2. Connect with me on LinkedIn and Medium for daily leadership strategies, insights, and commentary.