Reclaiming Focus: The Hidden Dangers of Push Notifications
Written on
Chapter 1: The Cost of Constant Notifications
Take a moment today to silence your phone.
Even the most well-meaning notifications can have surprising repercussions. On December 29, 1972, a fully functional passenger plane tragically crashed just 20 miles from Miami International Airport. As the aircraft approached the airport, a cockpit warning light indicated that the nose landing gear was not securely in place.
In the process of addressing this alert, the crew inadvertently switched off the autopilot, a detail that went unnoticed as their focus remained on the landing gear issue. As a result, the plane gradually descended until it was too late to react. The disaster ultimately claimed the lives of 101 individuals. While such extreme outcomes are rare, distractions like these are never beneficial to peak performance.
In today's world, the incessant push notifications from our phones may not lead to tragedy, but they pose a substantial risk to our cognitive abilities and mental wellness.
I recently joined a well-known social media platform to enhance my professional networking. I was taken aback by the intricate notification settings—ten main categories needed to be adjusted if I wanted to eliminate notifications entirely. Even during quiet moments, notifications would pop up: “Your weekly summary!” “Things you might have overlooked despite our relentless notifications!”
If allowed, my phone would bombard me with notifications every few minutes about the latest online happenings. Many people willingly endure this. A friend of mine, while we wrapped up a game of pickleball, picked up his phone to find it flooded with notifications—emails, texts, and likely the latest updates from social media. I could see the tension building in him. But does it matter?
The Performance Impact of Interruptions
We often believe we can multitask effectively. However, Anthony Wagner, PhD, a psychology professor at Stanford's Wu Tsai Neurosciences Institute, asserts that “multitasking is largely a misconception, as the human brain isn't built for performing multiple tasks at once.” Instead, what we perceive as multitasking is merely rapid switching between tasks.
This frequent task-switching exacts a toll. We tend to complete tasks more slowly and with greater errors, and it's all too easy to forget one task entirely. More times than I care to admit, I've found myself mindlessly scrolling through a website on my phone, unable to recall why I picked it up in the first place. Constant interruptions hinder my ability to think, converse, write, read, or engage in any meaningful activity.
The Wellness Impact of Digital Distractions
Allowing our phones to disrupt us negatively impacts cognitive functioning and overall performance in activities requiring focus. But what about our mental well-being? Specifically, let’s examine push notifications through the lens of mindfulness.
Managing my thoughts to fully enjoy the present moment is already a challenge; I certainly don’t need my phone complicating things further. Sam Harris, in his book Waking Up, writes, “By practicing mindfulness…one can awaken from the dream of discursive thought and begin to see each image, idea, or piece of language vanish without a trace.” The next notification isn’t likely to help us focus on the present; rather, it often pulls us back into a cycle of distractions.
Through mindfulness, we learn to detach from our thoughts. They will continue to arise, but we don't have to follow their distracting paths. Some thoughts can be beneficial if engaged at the right time, while others—like ruminations on a past comment from your boss—can simply be let go.
The issue with our phone notifications isn’t solely that they are irrelevant (though many are); it’s that they rarely convey urgent or life-altering information. Just as a mindful individual selectively engages with thoughts, one should also control which digital notifications to receive and when to engage with them.
Our engagement with the digital world should typically originate from us, not our devices.
Taking Charge of Your Notifications
Only you can determine what constitutes an urgent message and how those messages should reach you. This varies for each person based on their work and relationships, as well as the time of day or week. For instance, I have enabled notifications for five specific apps:
- Text messages, which primarily come from friends and family.
- My dog's GPS collar, so I'm alerted if he goes missing.
- A meditation app that reminds me to meditate.
- The medical communication system from my hospital.
- Phone calls, which I prefer for urgent communications.
Everything else on my phone is muted—no social media alerts, no news updates, and no banking notifications. Over fifty apps have requested permission to notify me, and I’ve turned them all down. Even my email app is set to silent. If something requires immediate attention, people know to text or call me. This way, when my phone does buzz or beep, it's likely to be an important message or a communication from someone I care about.
Ready to make your phone less intrusive? Set aside thirty minutes in your calendar to turn off notifications that don’t genuinely matter to you. Then, dedicate that time to something meaningful.
Chapter 2: Exploring the Consequences of Distractions
The first video titled "Why Is the Road to Hell Paved With 'Good' Intentions?" explores how even well-meaning actions can lead to unexpected negative outcomes.
The second video, "The Road to Hell Is Paved with Good Intentions," further delves into the complexities of intentions versus consequences in our digital age.